Cookie Jar Golf Podcast Episode 110

I joined Tom Mills and Sam Williams for a wide-ranging chat on everything from state of the game issues to vodka Pimms and bunch of things in between.

Hopefully you’ve seen some of the wonderful video profiles of courses and have signed up for their occasional newsletter to keep up with this non-British but British take on the game. Recent pods have included Zac Blair discussing his recent Heathlands trip, Matt Faldo and Keith Wood discussing the Faldo Series, along with their “diaries” issues that make for great listens.

The Google podcast link.

The Apple link.

The Cookie Jar podcast page.

Cookie Jar Golf’s website.

And their YouTube page where it’s free to subscribe.

"If only you could break away from the constraints of having someone else tell you how many holes you must build."

CNN’s Sean Coppack filed an excellent story and video feature on “how Iceland could reshape the world of golf". I could not embed so you’ll need to hit the link to watch.

There are some amazing reveals and scenery, but this on a course called Brautarholt, whose founder Gunnar Palsson shares words of wisdom about 12 holes. Or whatever is the right number for a site.

"This used to be agricultural land, but that had been declining," Palsson tells CNN Sport. "This land has been in the family for hundreds of years and there were some generational shifts and we decided to build a golf course."

Opening originally as a nine-hole course in 2011 before expanding to 12, Brautarholt was designed by renowned Icelandic architect Edwin Roald.

Roald has attracted plenty of attention in recent years with his "why 18-holes?" movement, a philosophy that suggests golf course design would be improved if architects worked to create the best course for the space they have, rather than cling onto the "antiquated" notion that every course must be 18-holes long.

"When you have limited resources, you are forced to use what nature has given you," Roald told Links magazine in 2017. "If only you could break away from the constraints of having someone else tell you how many holes you must build.

"It is the same as writing books, or making movies. Imagine if all books had to be exactly 200 pages, or a film had to last 95 minutes. Would they be as good?"

A Year Later, Cleeve Hill Hosts A "Not Closing" Party

Just a year after facing closure, the wild hilltop links that’s seen design work by Old Tom Morris and Alister MacKenzie celebrated its salvation and future of better care thanks to “Nick & Sam” of Cotswold Hub.

Congrats to all on saving this spectacular place in the game and for enjoying your work. A short video from the day by Cookie Jar Golf, who brought attention to the courses plight with a mini doc (embedded below).

Kenyon Points Out The Inconsistency Of New Green Reading Rules

The pending rule change attempting to restore certain skills by killing off green reading books and other gizmos has run into some criticism. And the point is a legitimate one but I have an easy solution.

Short game specialist Phil Kenyon argues in an Instagram post at the oddity of going after levels and other machinery possibly used to test green conditions. This seems like an effort to cut down on the number of people on greens, devices on greens or, if you’re a bit forward thinking, players bringing Stimpmeters or moisture-reading devices into the practice round equation. The entourages also add unnecessary traffic on the greens. Mostly, the art of golf’s rugged individualist scouting out things on their own is in danger.

Still Kenyon makes this point:

So you can take a TrackMan or quad or range finder on to the course and check how certain shots or holes “play” yardage wise but you can’t take a level onto a “practice” putting green to calibrate your feel for slope.

What a ridiculous rule. It’s stupid in fact. It serves no purpose. It’s indeed skill limiting.

I actually don’t think the governing bodies understand the complexity of the scenarios in front of them.

Is using a level in practice hurting the game more than how far the ball goes or the speed of play ?

There is an inconsistency here. Tee to fringe players can max out the technology and outside sources to gain insight, but once on the greens they must revert to conditions of a decade ago.

The easy solution: lose the launch monitors on the course. Oh, and stop providing slope-adjusted yardages in official books.

As for the ball going too far and slow play, well those two go hand in hand.

Kenyon’s full post:

Quadrilateral: Major(s) News And Notes, November 4, 2021

This week’s News and Notes already landed via email but here is the weekly free edition brimming with joyful anecdotes about the biggest events in golf. Included this week are some thoughts on the sneaky-huge ramifications of PGA Tour players taking initiative on the skill discussion, plus notes on Ryder Cup shirts of yesteryear, next year’s Women’s Open finally securing official tournament dates, a dreamy view of the Old Course up for sale and more.

As always, you can get a better understanding of what The Quad is about here or sign up for free here.

McKellar Podcast With Lawrence Donegan And Mark Cannizzaro

McKellar’s podcast is back and Lawrence Donegan and Mark Cannizzaro included yours truly in a discussion about Golf Saudi’s infusion of cash into the Asian Tour. We explore the possibility of anarchy should top players take some huge cash offers, plus the flaw in the concept and some of the people who’ve signed on to support the effort to remake professional golf.

Listening options: Apple, Spotify or wherever you get your pods.

Finally: Amateur Golfers Can Cash In On NIL! Just Don't Charge For A Lesson

It was a brief but glorious time in which college golfers could cash in on their name, image, likeness and really good golfing ability—as long as they didn’t give a less or accept cash prizes over $750. And now it’s over, as all amateur golfers of all ages can cash in on endorsements, assuming such deals are not in conflict with their league eligibility. See your local compliance officer for more details.

Below is the press release. You’re better off going to one of these links:

Guidance Notes (scroll a lot to get to the above embedded portion on how to go full logoclad).

Glorious infographics for those golfers who like pretty pictures instead of that pesky fine print.

Rules of Amateur Status.

For Immediate Release:

Golf's Modernized Rules of Amateur Status Published 

LIBERTY CORNER, N.J. USA AND ST ANDREWS, Scotland (Oct. 26, 2021) - Golf’s new Rules of Amateur Status have been published by the USGA and The R&A ahead of their January 1, 2022, effective date.  

The work is the latest step by the governing bodies to make the Rules easier to understand and apply and follows the modernization process of the Rules of Golf in 2019. The new Rules were informed by golfer and golf industry feedback as a part of a comprehensive review, to ensure they continue to reflect how the modern game is played by millions of golfers around the world.

This review, along with the global feedback received when the proposals were publicly shared earlier this year, reaffirmed amateur golf’s important position in the game and the value in maintaining amateur status Rules. 

The result is a set of Rules that removes many of the restrictions that previously applied to amateur golfers, while ensuring that the integrity of the game is protected by limiting the form and value of the prizes an amateur golfer can accept. 

As part of the modernization effort, the new Rules identify only the following acts that will result in a golfer losing their amateur status:

  • Accepting a prize with a value exceeding the prize limit ($1000/£700) or accepting prize money in a handicap competition.

  • Playing as a professional.

  • Accepting payment for giving instruction (although all current exceptions still apply, such as coaching at educational institutions and assisting with approved programs).

  • Accepting employment as a golf club professional or membership of an association of professional golfers

To achieve this simplified approach, the following key changes have been introduced:

  • Distinguishing between scratch and handicap competitions in terms of the prizes that may be accepted.

  • The prize rule applies only to tee-to-hole competitions played on a golf course or a simulator, but no longer apply to long-drive, putting and skills competitions that are not played as part of a tee-to-hole competition.

  • Eliminating all advertising, expense-related and sponsorship restrictions.

The new opportunities provided by lifting sponsorship restrictions and the ability to accept prize money up to the increased limit of $1000 or £700 in scratch-only competitions will be of significant benefit to elite amateur golfers looking for ways to fund golf-related expenses.

“Golf is unique in its broad appeal to both recreational and competitive players,” said Craig Winter, USGA senior director, Rules of Golf and Amateur Status. “This was emphasized in the feedback we received earlier this year and we believe these updates will help simplify these Rules and ensure the long-term health of the amateur game, not only to those who compete at the highest level of amateur golf, but for the millions of golfers at every age and skill level who enjoy competitive events at their home courses.”

Grant Moir, Director of Rules at The R&A, said, “We are delighted to be rolling out the modernized Rules of Amateur Status today. These Rules play an important role in protecting the integrity of our self-regulating sport, but the code must evolve to meet the needs of the modern game. This is particularly important for modern elite amateur golf, where many of the players need financial support to compete and develop to their full potential. The new Rules give them this opportunity and will help to make the game even more inclusive.” 

The new Rules are accompanied by guidance notes, an overview document and explanations that detail the rationale for why changes have been made and, in some instances, why they have stayed the same. 

These materials can be found at www.usga.org/amateurstatus

21,281 Counterfeit Clubs Seized In China Raids, Integrity Of The Game Threatened?

Here is David Dusek’s Golfweek report on counterfeit clubs seized in six-raids last month and how consumers can spot the hot stuff.

This seems a tad dramatic though:

“As golf continues to grow in popularity, counterfeiters are taking drastic measures to deceive the public and threaten the integrity of the game,” said Daryl Rocco, Senior Paralegal for Callaway, in a release.

Integrity of the game?

The Sandbelt Invitational Steps In After Australian Open Cancellations

Royal Melbourne

Exciting news from Down Under: Geoff Ogilvy and Mike Clayton are teaming up to create The Sandbelt Invitational just before Christmas, December 20-23, 2021. The four course event will feature Royal Melbourne, Kingston Heath, Yarra Yarra and Peninsula Kingswood with men and women, pros and amateurs.

As the feature below lays out, the event has been created to give Australian pros an opportunity to compete after losing this year’s Australian Opens.

My favorite part in this clip? Seeing “Tournament Director” under Mike Clayton’s name!

State Of The Game 116: So-Yeon Ryu

Screen Shot 2021-10-17 at 4.13.10 PM.png

Rod Morri, Mike Clayton and yours truly enjoyed a wide-ranging conversation with 21-time international winner and two-time major winner So-Yeon Ryu. We cover a lot, including what this former Chevron (gulp) champion thinks of the event move to an unnamed course in Houston. Warning: very little rollback talk. Apologies to those drinking and listening.

The SOG 116 page is here for all your listening options.

"There will be solutions but this is not that solution. What they are, we’re not sure yet, but this is not it."

Mike Stachura covers a lot of ground on the driver length “Model Local Rule” here, including early signs of more players going longer, the supportive stance of the PGA Tour, and the overall theme of this as a proactive move instead of reactive.

If that wasn’t clear, this from the USGA’s Thomas Pagel leaves no grey area about what lies ahead.

“We’re committed to our desire to stop the cycle of increased hitting distances. We have the long-term health of the game in mind. How is the game healthy 20, 50, 100 years from now. That’s something we \remain committed to. We know elite players can achieve distance increases through using a longer club, and as an industry as we go through the critical conversation about the long-term health of the game and what role distance plays with that, we just thought it was best to cap this now while we have the rest of that discussion.”

Quadrilateral: Major(s) News And Notes, October 14th, 2021

I had to leave a few lesser notes on the cutting room floor but there’s always next week! In the meantime, we have plenty to chew on with the 46-inch Local Rule reactions ensuring widespread adoption in 2022's majors. But Phil doesn't agree and I speculate as to why.

Plus, a cow pasture wants the '31 Ryder Cup, Masters job offerings and a whole bunch of good reads both on golf and not

This would already have landed in your inbox if you signed up. And of course, if you have and a paid subscriber you can comment and read all past issues.